Normal Thyroid Labs but Still Have Symptoms? What to Know

head_shot_ari
Content By: Ari Whitten

Most people’s thyroid care is completely wrong, and they can feel it.

Conventional medicine often tests one marker and prescribes only one medication, then calls it a day. 

But Dr. Amie Hornaman, founder of the Advanced Thyroid and Hormone Clinic, is challenging everything we thought we knew about thyroid health. 

In this episode, we discuss the latest thyroid research that’s being ignored by mainstream medicine. We discuss why your “normal” lab results might actually be making you sick, and how to know if you really need thyroid hormone replacement. 

Dr. Amie brings her signature no-nonsense approach to topics like the forgotten thyroid hormone, black cumin seed oil for autoimmune thyroid, iodine dosing, and why treating the person matters infinitely more than chasing optimal numbers. 

Table of Contents

In this podcast, Dr. Hornaman and I discuss: 

  • Why conventional medicine’s one-test, one-medication approach to thyroid is fundamentally broken 
  • The critical difference between “normal” lab ranges and truly optimal thyroid function (these aren’t just “functional” ranges)
  • How to know if you actually need thyroid hormone replacement or if you’re fine as-is 
  • T2: the forgotten thyroid hormone that burns fat without suppressing your thyroid 
  • Why T3 can be dangerous if not dosed correctly, and how to do it right 
  • Black cumin seed oil: how it supports Hashimoto’s and the incredible results Dr. Hornaman has seen in her practice 
  • The iodine controversy: why both sides are wrong and how to dose it safely 
  • How high-level athletes naturally have lower thyroid hormone and why that’s not pathology 
  • The role of gut health in T4 to T3 conversion and thyroid optimization 
  • Why hormone replacement is different from “band-aid medications” and when you should embrace it 

Listen or download on iTunes

Listen outside iTunes

Transcript

Ari Whitten: Hey, this is Ari. Welcome back to the Energy Blueprint Podcast. With me in today’s episode is Dr. Amie Hornaman, who is the founder of the Advanced Thyroid and Hormone Clinic. She’s a functional health practitioner who specializes in thyroid function, and she’s become one of the most recognized and unapologetically outspoken voices challenging the conventional approach to thyroid care. This is a wide-ranging conversation covering a lot of topics around thyroid gland function that you won’t necessarily hear talked about in other conversations on the topic of the thyroid. We get into a lot of cool stuff that I think you will find very, very interesting. With no further ado, enjoy this conversation with Dr. Amie Hornaman. Dr. Amie, welcome back to the show.

Dr. Amie Hornaman: Ari, thank you so much. I’m excited to be here.

Why Conventional Thyroid Care May Miss Symptoms

Ari: I have done, over the years of this podcast, I think close to a decade at this point, I’ve done God knows how many podcasts on the subject of the thyroid, but I have not done one in a while, in several years. I’m excited to get back into this with you, and I’m excited to hear what’s the latest and greatest thinking, the updates, the science, and that sort of thing on this topic. Is there anything that jumps out in your mind as far as an evolution in thinking around thyroid health? What are the latest trends and how people are thinking about thyroid health in new ways?

Dr. Amie: Yes, absolutely. I guess the answer to that question is yes and no. I’ll start with the no, and then we’ll get to the yes. The no answer is that unfortunately, in the world of conventional sick medicine, as we know it, we haven’t seen many advances. I can go back 30 years to when I was misdiagnosed and undiagnosed and mistreated. I look at even the patients that we see today in the clinic, they’re still going through the same thing.

It’s like we haven’t really advanced in our medical system, medical school training on the importance of the thyroid literally being the master gland, dictating your mood, your blood sugar regulation, your digestion, your metabolism, your mitochondrial function. That’s how important the thyroid is, and it boggles my mind as to why we’re not having more and more and more of a spotlight on it in the conventional medicine space. There’s that.

Now, in the world that we live in and the world that your listeners live in, where they are a little bit more elevated, they pay attention, they take care of themselves, they want to feel their absolute best, we are seeing some new things come up, not necessarily in how we treat, because at the end of the day, in clinic, in our functional medicine space, we are treating you as a unique individual, we are getting you optimized. Not just normal, because normal is a setting on the dryer. We don’t use the word normal to describe your health. We’re getting you into that optimized state. At the end of the day, that is our goal. That’s all of our goal collectively.

What we are seeing, and it’s a lot more in the media, and I know you and I were talking about this a little bit before we started, it’s a touchy subject, but I’m going to bring it up because we’re having a spotlight on it in the news. The Lindsay Clancy case. What we are seeing, and again, this isn’t talking about the case itself and where you fall opinion-wise, what blew me away, Ari, is when I was watching some of the court proceedings, and this is going back a month or so. I don’t even know where they are right now with the trial. That’s how much I keep up on it.

Thyroid Hormones, Depression, Anxiety and Mental Health

What made my jaw drop at the time is a friend sent me a clip of the actual trial that they were televising. At one point of time, there’s a doctor on the stand the defense is interviewing and calling out the thyroid. They literally put the thyroid on trial as an integral part of a woman’s mood, mental state, anxiety, depression. We know this. We know this as clinicians. We know the thyroid is important for your brain function. There are more receptor sites on the brain for thyroid hormone than anywhere else in the body. When we’re looking at things, even in the world of functional psychiatry, we are now seeing functional psychiatrists using T3, the active thyroid hormone, or natural desiccated thyroid medication that contains T3, we’re seeing them use that in place of lithium, antipsychotics for bipolar and schizophrenia.

We know if functional psychiatry is starting to pay more and more and more attention to the thyroid and using thyroid hormone replacement as a treatment, then obviously in, let’s say, the lower-tier mental health model where people are just dealing with anxiety, dealing with depression, not related to a circumstance. It’s just happening. That brain chemistry mix-up that occurs, very much tied to thyroid. We know that antidepressants are almost like the number one band-aid next to birth control that doctors will reach for when a woman comes in and says, “Hey, Doc, I’m really struggling here. I’m gaining weight. I’m moody. I’m depressed for no reason. I can’t sleep.” “Oh, well, here’s an antidepressant.” How about we go, “Let’s step back and look at your thyroid. Let’s look at the master gland before we start band-aiding with antidepressants and birth control.”

Hashimoto's, Autoimmunity, Black Cumin and LDN

Ari: Got it. Is there any recent research on the autoimmune element of thyroid that’s changing anything, that’s changing the views that practitioners are holding or the approach in any way?

Dr. Amie: Well, I will say, and again, it’s almost like it has this potential to break through and come into mainstream, but I feel like it’s still back here in our world. I feel like we live in a different health bubble than the rest of the population. What do we know? We know that the exposure to toxins and pesticides and the rise of glyphosate and EMF exposure and all these things that we’re talking more and more about that are impacting our bodies, let’s say, as opposed or compared to our parents or our grandparents, they lived in a totally different set of toxins or maybe neurotoxin than we do right now. We know that that plays a role in autoimmunity. Across the board, we know that.

I think the other thing that we see that maybe mainstream people don’t see, or even mainstream practitioners aren’t diving into, is the role that autoimmune seed oil and the research behind that in reducing inflammation and reducing antibodies. Literally, we’ve had some patients go into full remission for their Hashimoto’s, their autoimmune conditions by using black cumin. It’s a very, very powerful compound that you don’t hear that much about. It’s available in supplemental form, but you don’t hear that much about it. It’s so powerful in the world of autoimmune.

We do hear a little bit about low-dose naltrexone, which LDN, or low-dose naltrexone, is a medication. It has to be compounded, so you do have to be working with a practitioner that will prescribe it. That works very well at lowering inflammation, reducing autoimmune antibodies, all the things, but so does black cumin seed oil. What I find with black cumin seed in our patient population, they tolerate it much better. With LDN, some people will get a cortisol spike. Some people will get a flat affect experience where their mood just flattens out, almost like a severe antidepressant effect, but too much to where you lose your feeling.

We’ll see that with LDN I would say in about 30% of the population. We’ll also see sleep disorders. It doesn’t matter what time of the day that you put it. Nightmares, sleep issues where black cumin seed doesn’t really have that effect. We use a lot more black cumin, in addition to lifestyle changes, of course, going gluten-free, all the things, to put Hashimoto’s into remission because we can only control our environment as much as we can control it.

Black Cumin Seeds vs. Oil: Understanding Thymoquinone

Ari: Right. Real quick detail question on the black cumin. You mentioned black cumin seed oil. I remember seeing one of the studies where I think they used crushed black cumin seeds rather than just the oil extracted, if I’m remembering correctly. You correct me if I’m wrong. Do you think that there’s a distinction there between taking the whole seed versus just the seed oil?

Dr. Amie: That’s a great question. I’d have to dig into it. I do know this. I know that when we are looking at black cumin seed or black cumin seed oil, let’s say in supplemental form, you want to look for the thymoquinone percent. Thymoquinone is the active ingredient. That’s really what does the job with black cumin. Now, I don’t know if that– like the case with flax seeds where you have to crush them, you have to actually break them with your teeth if you have the whole seed in order to get the omega-3s and the good fats out of it. It might be the same with black cumin where you do have to crush it to get that thymoquinone activation, but I’m honestly not sure.

Ari: I believe it is the case. You do have to break down the shell of the seed to get most of those active compounds. I think that in one of those studies that they used crushed black cumin seeds, like the powder rather than whole seeds and rather than the oil. Oftentimes with these plant compounds, sometimes the whole is greater than the sum of the parts in the sense that there are complementary compounds that maybe also have effects. There’s entourage effects that an individual compound extracted isn’t as powerful as taking in the whole plant or the whole extract, the full spectrum extract.

What Is T2? The Forgotten Thyroid Hormone

Dr. Amie: Yes, exactly. The other really cool thing that we’re seeing come out, since we’re on the topic of new innovations and even in the supplement world, I mentioned earlier as well off-camera, T2, which I call T2 the forgotten thyroid hormone because our thyroid gland actually does produce T1, T2, T3, and T4. Now we hear about T3 and T4 because we can test for it and because it’s in pharmaceutical form. Anything that’s in Big Pharma form, even if it’s fantastic for you, I’m nothing against T3, T4, NDT. We use it all the time in practice that we’re going to replace your thyroid hormones that aren’t being made properly by your thyroid anymore.

T2 is in supplemental form, which in my opinion is why we don’t hear a lot about it because Big Pharma can’t make money off of it. It is in supplemental form, and it’s a thyroid hormone. When we look at the studies, it has over 30 years of research behind it. Now, unfortunately, only to human studies because why? Big Pharma doesn’t have it so they’re not going to put the money behind it to do human trials or randomized controlled human trials. When we do look at the study–

Ari: Quick questions and sorry to interrupt, but what are the specifics around why pharmaceutical companies can’t make T2? They do have T3 and T4. Is that not true?

Dr. Amie: That is true. That is true. It’s not that they can’t, they almost did. Ari, we don’t want them to grab hold of the T2. I don’t want them to take control of it. There was a 2020 study, and this is very interesting, a 2020 study that came out. The first line of the study was something along the lines of T2 or 3,5-diiodo-L-thyronine, which is the big, long name for it, is on the precipice of being our next answer to the obesity crisis that we’re in right now in America. I saw this after 2020, and I thought to myself, “Oh, my gosh, it almost became the weight loss drug, but guess what beat it? GLPs.

I truly believe that the rise of GLPs, which occurred basically in 2020, now they’ve been around for a while, but when did we really start hearing about it? When did Hollywood start using GLPs to lose the last 10 pounds? 2020 and 2021. That’s really where we saw the rise of it. Then, Big Pharma saw dollar signs, and here we go. Now, again, I’m not anti-GLP, but the reality is that’s what won. I think it was going to be picked up by Big Pharma at one point, and then along came GLPs.

T2, Metabolism, Fat Burning and Muscle Mass

Ari: I see. All right, continue talking about the impact of T2.

Dr. Amie: T2. It literally increases your basal metabolic rate, so your BMR, the amount of fat that you’re burning at rest. We know that it decreases inflammation. It browns white adipose tissue. One of the reasons why we might jump into a cold plunge is to essentially brown that white fat. We have the white squishy fat that surrounds our organs that we grab, and we say, “I don’t want this here,” as we grab our sides. That is the fat that we want to brown. Now, you might say, “Wait, why do we want more fat? Fat is fat. I want to get rid of it.” No. Brown adipose tissue is more metabolically active. It has mitochondria in it. It’s basically what we see on babies, very active fat, very protective fat.

If we can brown that white adipose tissue, we reduce inflammation, we have better metabolism. We’re just set up for success overall. It also lowers inflammation. It helps to convert that T4 thyroid hormone, that inactive thyroid hormone, into the active thyroid hormone, so it helps with T4 to T3 conversion. The biggest part of this whole thing, it’s non-stimulant. Even though it is a fat burner, essentially, it doesn’t jack up your heart rate. It has no cardiovascular side effect to where you’re going to feel like you just drank 10 Red Bulls and you might have a heart attack from the fat burners, days of old fat burners.

Then the other thing is it doesn’t change your thyroid labs. I always like to go back to my roots of bodybuilding. I always say bodybuilders are the OGs of biohacking, where we experimented on ourselves long before Dave Asprey started injecting peptides. We were doing it first. I saw this interview. He was one of the top trainers to the pro athletes in the world of bodybuilding. He mainly worked with women. He said, “I don’t let my female athletes use T3.” What he means by that is, right or wrong, bodybuilders will use thyroid hormone off the black market, specifically T3, to increase their metabolism and lose body fat before a show.

Thyroid hormone, it controls your metabolism. We already said that. It has control over your metabolic rate. Bodybuilders will use T3. They’ll get off the black market. They’ll start taking it. It’ll rev up their metabolism, help them lose body fat for the show. Here’s the problem, is that thyroid hormone has a feedback loop to your brain, which is essentially going to create a hypothyroid state after that athlete stops taking T3. Now you took T3 for 8 to 12 weeks. Now you have a thyroid problem. Now you are going to have to be on thyroid hormone the rest of your life because you used and abused it. It literally changed your whole thyroid profile.

He says, “I don’t let my female athletes use T3 because they’re going to burn their muscle too, along with their fat.” That’s the other thing, is that if you artificially jack up your metabolism, you’re burning fat and muscle at the same time, not just body fat. They’re going to have a problem with their thyroid after. He goes, “I only let them use T2 because it doesn’t have an effect on their thyroid. It doesn’t produce that negative feedback loop. Their thyroid labs aren’t going to change. They’re not going to have a thyroid problem where they need medication after the show. It only targets their body fat and not their muscle.” I was like, “Well, that’s a win-win right there, bro. Yes, that sounds good to me.” Yes, it really is fascinating when you start diving into the research on T2.

T2 Supplements: Availability and Practical Uses

Ari: Is T2 something people can get anywhere? Is there any practical way of using T2?

Dr. Amie: We brought it into our line. We do have it in our Fixer Formula line. It started in the bro science world too. Just like bodybuilders or the OGs of biohacking, T2 started with the power lifters and the bodybuilders. I kid you not, Ari, I’m sitting with these ladies. It was back in the days of my brick and mortar before we could prescribe to all 50 states. I’m sitting there with these women. They’re coming in to see me from New York, California. There’s nothing I can do. We got to maybe work with your doctor, beg your doctor for some T3.

We need to break past this metabolic wall because their thyroid wasn’t being treated properly. It was being treated just like you’ve talked about on the show before in past episodes. Conventional medicine does one test only, treats with one medication. They call it a day. That is it. These poor women are– and I say women because they get hit more with thyroid problems. These poor people are struggling with all the symptoms of thyroid. They’ve gained the weight. They can’t lose it no matter what they do. They’re tracking their macros. They’re doing all the things. I’d be sitting across from them going, “Okay, just take this supplement and trust me.” It had a gorilla on it with claw marks.

The woman’s like, “My husband’s looking at me like I got five heads. Am I really going to take this supplement home and sit it on my counter? He’s going to think I’m going to die if I take this supplement.” When I started [unintelligible 00:18:53] I brought T2 into it. Since then, I’ve just been studying, studying, studying, making notes, taking data, even getting data from our patients that started. We’ll look at their thyroid labs before. We’ll look at them after 12 weeks of use. We see nothing is changing for the worse. It’s changing for the better, but it’s not changing for the worse. They’re not going hyper. It’s not affecting their cardiovascular markers. We’re seeing just improvements across the board.

T2 Side Effects, Thyroid Suppression and Dosing

Ari: Is there any concern with side effects or suppression of thyroid hormone production?

Dr. Amie: No, that’s the beauty. No suppression of thyroid hormone production because it’s working at the mitochondria level. It’s not giving that negative feedback loop to the brain, to the hypothalamus and pituitary. The only side effects are in those really sensitive people. There’s no stimulating effect of T2, but you’re always going to have that subset of people that they get jacked up on Benadryl. You give the woman a drop of estrogen and she blows up like a balloon. The really, really sensitive people will report back a stimulation effect. For them, we just start really slow. We might say, “You know what? Start with the T2 cream that’s 50 milligrams, that’s a nice lower dose, and let your body get used to it and build up.” I’d say the majority of people can start right away.

Ari: That’s a topical cream?

Dr. Amie: That’s a topical, yes. We made a T2 cream with glutathione for topical to lower dose. Then we have a powder in Metabolism Fixer that’s at a 75-microgram dose per serving. Then we have Thyroid Fixer, which is capsule, and that’s 100 micrograms per capsule. You can really find your sweet spot. The human studies went up to 300 micrograms a day where they showed an average of 9-pound weight loss in 28 days, an average reduction of a 4% reduction in body fat. They used 300, but honestly, you find your sweet spot. It’s like vitamin D. When you’re trying to raise your vitamin D, if it’s in the toilet, you might be taking 20,000 IUs per day. If you’re floating good and you’re coming in with a vitamin D level of a 90, maybe you only need 5,000 or 10,000 a day to keep it afloat.

Ari: T2 also doesn’t negatively affect muscle mass the way that T3 does?

Dr. Amie: Correct. That’s the really cool thing. Personal story for me, I am on T3 only. I have been for decades. I’m the opposite of sensitive. I just need more. I need a higher dose of testosterone, a higher dose of estrogen, a higher dose of T3. I can take handfuls of supplements. They don’t bother me. I don’t have any kind of sensitivity. With my T3 dosing, I was taking 75 micrograms twice a day. Now, that’s a lot. Yes, I absolutely did have some muscle burn because I work out the same way as I did when I was competing. I really struggled with getting that nice cap on my shoulders, the bicep. My whole life, I’ve struggled with that.

When I added in T2, I actually started doing an experiment with myself. I’m like, “I’m going to see if I can lower my T3 dose.” I started pulling back. I’m like, “Okay, is anything happening? Am I going hypo? Am I feeling like I’m sliding backwards?” Nothing was occurring. I kept symptom-free, feeling good, optimized, the whole thing. Then I pulled back even more. Now, I did this about two years ago. I can honestly say that in reducing my T3 dose, because I added in T2, I can now put on muscle. I can now see the changes in my upper body, my body composition.

I’m 52. I should be losing muscle, but I’m not. Actually, I have more muscle now than I did when I was competing because, my gosh, I was doing T3. I was doing way too much cardio. That’s a whole other discussion. I think I was just burning through my muscle. Yes, absolutely, it only targets body fat.

Ari: I was just browsing a little bit. It seems like very few people are selling T2 in supplement form. You are, and I found your site very quickly. Why is it? Why have other people not caught on to this? I actually remember reading on T2 myself maybe 15 years ago and buying some supplement that had T2 in it to try to support fat loss a long, long time ago. Why is it that there’s still so few people using this in supplement formulas?

Dr. Amie: That’s a great question. I hope they stay away. We like cornering the market. Honestly, my guess, we’re really, really picky with where we source ours. That’s one thing. It’s very, very expensive, and we are very, very picky of where we source it. We test it coming out of the facility that we get the bulk product before it goes to manufacturing. We’re testing it all along the way. It’s heavy lifting. It’s an expense. I’m just wondering maybe supplement companies don’t want to go that route. Yes, that’s a great question. I don’t know.

Low Free T3: When Should Thyroid Hormones Be Treated?

Ari: One of the things I want to talk about is the autoimmune side of this. Maybe one good thing that I’d like to get your opinion on is, there is this spectrum between, on the one hand, you have, let’s say, people who are quick to prescribe supplemental T3 or T4, let’s say T3, if someone has a sub-clinical– let’s say they’re on the low end of normal for T3. There are certain practitioners who are very quick to say, “Well, let’s optimize that, and let’s get you on T3 so that we can get your levels back up to normal or in a more optimal range.”

There are other practitioners who oppose this and say that, no, this is not actually a pathology. This is not something that you should treat. Maybe even practitioners who argue that there is a danger with overuse of T3 in this kind of context and where the T3 may do more harm than good. Can you speak to that landscape and portray maybe better than I have what the arguments are, the best arguments are on both sides and where you land on that?

Dr. Amie: Absolutely. I love this. I absolutely love this question. At the end of the day, every single person should be treated as a unique individual. It doesn’t matter what this person’s view is. It doesn’t matter what that person’s view is. It doesn’t matter the credential that this person or that person has and what they’re saying on IG. You are a unique individual. Let’s say I’m sitting down with a patient. I am going to, number one, look at his or her labs because those labs are data points. Now, we know the labs aren’t the be-all, end-all, and you are so much more than just the lab value, but they really give me data.

Before we even look at the labs, I’m going to ask you, how do you feel? Because ultimately, that gives me more clinical information than numbers on a paper. You telling me your symptoms, how long you’ve had them, how debilitating they are, how are they affecting your life, that’s going to determine a lot. If I have Sally sitting in front of me and she’s like, “Okay, I’m up 20 pounds. It came on rapid. I’m doing everything. I’m counting my macros. I’m doing protein first. I’m exercising. I’m doing the Pilates. I’m meditating. I’m looking at the sun. I’m going to bed at 10:00. I’m wearing my blue light blocking glasses. I’m doing all the things. I’m standing in front of the red light, and it’s just not working. I’m really tired. I’m losing my hair. It’s starting to affect my marriage and my sex life. I love my husband. I just don’t want sex with him. My skin looks like it’s aging rapidly. I’m bloated all the time.” I hear her and I hear the cry for help. It is affecting her quality of life.

Now let’s move over here and look at the labs. Then we go, “Okay, Sally, yes, well, you have Hashimoto’s.” “Oh, do I?” “Yes, you probably had it for like a decade. With these antibodies, what’s happening is it’s slowly destroying your thyroid gland. Nobody caught it. Nobody told you what to do. Nobody intervened early. We can ultrasound your thyroid, it’s probably going to look like Pac-Man attacked it. It’s going to be smaller. Obviously, it’s the smaller thyroid gland that’s been attacked. It’s going to produce the proper amounts of thyroid hormone.

As we can see here, your free T3, it’s a 2.4. That’s at the low end of even the normal standard lab value range. I want to see you more like a 3.5, 3.7, 3.9. That would be more optimal. It’s pairing up with your symptoms.” At this point in time, Sally’s life is being so affected. We need to replace the hormones that are longer being properly made by your body. Now, if it’s done properly by people who know what they’re doing, then Sally’s not going to be over-medicated. It’s not going to be harmful. She’s just going to feel her life come back and her body come back as her cells get what they need.

Now, the flip side of that would be, let’s say I’m talking to John. I’m like, “John, how do you feel?” “Girl, I’m living my best life. I got a libido. I got motivation. I got energy. I’m hitting the gym. I feel great about my body composition. I can even eat a little bit of something like gluten-free pizza and a beer. I don’t gain weight. It’s awesome. I feel fantastic.” I move over here to John’s labs, and I see a free T3 of a 2.4, same as Sally’s. Antibodies, yes, present. “Okay, John, you got Hashimoto’s and you’re free too.” Am I going to treat this with thyroid hormone replacement? No. John’s feeling great.”

How you feel is key. Honestly, my rule of thumb is, no matter what practitioner you’re working with, MD, DO, PA, NP, I don’t care what they have after their name, if they don’t ask you, how do you feel, then you’re with the wrong person because they’re going to treat you either with just as a lab value and throw meds at you, or they’re going to be at the other end. You mentioned, Ari, where they’re like, “No, let’s just do everything supplementally and lifestyle-wise.”

Now, what concerns me about just doing everything supplementally and lifestyle-wise is, can you prescribe? Are you trying to BS this person into doing your natural healing program because you literally can’t write them a prescription for what they need? That I am opposed to. It’s one thing to treat somebody because they don’t have symptoms. Yes, we’re going to intervene with nutritional changes and supplemental changes and support nutrient-wise and give the thyroid all the nutrients that it needs versus, “Oh, I can’t actually give you what you need, so I’m just going to BS you and sell you my thyroid healing program for $97.” No. It has to be individual which direction we go.

Low T3 in Athletes: Healthy Adaptation or Hypothyroidism?

Ari: Two aspects of this discussion that I think are important to address. One is, is there an aspect of normal, healthy, adaptive lowering of thyroid hormone where there’s danger of maybe pathologizing or treating that when it shouldn’t be? The context of that, for example, there’s research showing that high-level athletes and people who do a ton of exercise, people who are very lean, are often on the lower end of thyroid hormone output. This may not indicate any pathology or problem. It just may be that part of the body’s adaptive response to doing so much exercise and being so lean is to start to say, “Hey, let’s not put the accelerator pedal so hard on resting metabolic rate and maybe try to preserve energy at rest since we’re burning so much energy so much of the time.”

Is there a danger of maybe treating people who shouldn’t be treated? Then also, in the case of using exogenous thyroid hormone, given negative feedback loops, is there a danger of, let’s say, for example, you said somebody’s at the low 2s in free T3, and you want to see them more like 3.5. Now, if we’re prescribing T3, is there a danger where now you’re suppressing their natural thyroid hormone output even more as a result of that?

Dr. Amie: Yes, yes, and yes. I’ll unpack all that. Great questions. Let’s start with the athlete. All day. All day long. Yes, that’s exactly what can happen. There’s cortisol and thyroid hormone playing the same sandbox as well. We know exercise will increase cortisol. That’ll decrease thyroid hormone production, decrease conversion all day. Then it comes back to, for, let’s say, that person, they’re not going to be complaining about symptoms. They’re taking care of themselves. They feel amazing. No, it falls under that same category as John, where that athlete is reporting no symptoms whatsoever. Therefore, we’re not going to treat a number on a paper. We’re going to treat the person. All day long, you have to treat the person.

The Risks of Too Much Thyroid Hormone

Ari: Sorry to interrupt real quick. I agree completely with everything you’re saying, but I feel like there are many practitioners and many people who are not applying that context, who are just treating the number on the paper, who are just going by this heuristic of, “Oh, the optimal range of thyroid hormone is, let’s say, 3.5. I’m at a 2.5. Therefore, I need exogenous thyroid hormone so that I can be optimal regardless of how they feel.” The number on the paper is a more important indicator of what they think is their health status than how they feel.

Dr. Amie: Yes. In that context, you can absolutely do more harm than good. You absolutely can because, again, when we look at, from head to toe, the thyroid runs the show, that includes your heart. If you give too much thyroid hormone, even T4 thyroid hormone that’s inactive, you can give too much of any hormone and have a physiological effect on the body that isn’t good. I don’t care if we’re talking about testosterone, estrogen, T3, T4, whatever it is. Absolutely, you can tip the scale the other way and do some harm. You can cause AFib. You can cause tachycardia. You can send that person into a hyperthyroid state, which has a much more dangerous profile than being hypothyroid.

Hypothyroid will erode your body and cause disease states over time. It’s like the tortoise and the hare. Slowly, slowly, over time, yes, untreated thyroid can increase your risk of cancer, cause dementia, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, all of that, but that’s over time. You really have to be low and slow for a long time. Over on the hyper side, you jack someone up and make them hyper, they can have problems really, really quickly. It’s like the hare, very fast acting. Yes, 100%. Again, I come back to, if you are not being asked how you feel, that’s incorrect treatment, if your practitioner is only treating a number because they’re trying to push you into that optimal state.

Normal Thyroid Labs but Still Feel Awful?

Listen, we can give you optimal numbers all day long. The purpose of giving you an optimal versus normal range is just to shed light on the fact that so many people go into their doctor, they get their thyroid labs done, they’re told, “Your labs are normal.” We hear that all the time. We see it on social media. Normal, normal, normal. You have normal labs. There’s something to that because those practitioners are going by the standard reference range that’s on your lab. Next to your result, you have that standard lab value range, that standard reference range, which we know was taken from groups of sick people.

It’s one thing to say, “Okay, I don’t want you to fall in this huge range and be dismissed and told that you’re normal when you’re feeling like garbage.” On the other side, we’re also not– you’re optimal is you’re optimal. I use this example a ton. I could have two women sitting in front of me. Both of them have a free T3 of a 2.9. Not quite optimal, not horrible. It’s not in the bottom of the barrel of the range, but it’s not quite optimal. One woman is living her best life. One is riddled with symptoms. What do you do? If it ain’t broke, you don’t fix it.

Number one, the woman that’s living her best life, you leave her steady. If she’s on no medication, no medication. If she’s on a little bit of it, keep her on that same dose. The woman that has the 2.9, that’s riddled with symptoms, you treat her. I know I’m very much simplifying this for the sake of our time, but of course, needless to say, you look at all the other factors too. Yes, the thyroid, master gland, we want to test it. We want to optimize it. Then what else is going on? Is your cortisol out of whack? Are you under large amounts of stress? Are you insulin resistant? Are you nutrient depleted? Do you have gut issues?

You have to look at all these other things, of course, because they all play a role in thyroid function. They feed thyroid function. The gut is responsible for 80% of T4 to T3 conversions. Again, if your reverse T3 is high, your free T3 is low, and your gut’s a disaster, let’s work on the gut to see if we can’t push that T4 to T3 conversion more. Let’s make sure you have all the nutrients necessary for that to happen before we start throwing medication at you. It really just comes down to that unique individual.

Ari: Actually, before I get there, one last thing I want to ask you on this topic, which is, in this scenario that I’m describing where someone has maybe adaptive lowering of thyroid hormone of, let’s say, free T3, and they’re on, let’s say, the lower end of normal, if a practitioner treats that and says, “Hey, you’re too low, let’s optimize this. Let’s get you up to 3.5 or whatever by giving you exogenous T3,” given the harms of hyperthyroidism, I wonder if it’s possible to essentially get a functionally hyperthyroid effect while technically being in the normal or even optimal range in that context. Do you understand my question?

Dr. Amie: Do you mean from a feeling standpoint? They actually feel hyper with elevated heart rate, anxiety, that kind of thing?

Why Low T3 Doesn't Always Need Treatment

Ari: Not necessarily in manifesting in symptoms like that, in noticeable problematic symptoms. If the body is intelligently lowering T3, free T3, and it is therefore at the correct level for that person, at the lower end of normal, let’s say, that person is now taking exogenous T3, the body has an excess of T3, even though objectively on the blood test results, they would be still testing within the normal range.

Dr. Amie: Got you. Again, it’s like, where is that person’s baseline symptom, symptomatology profile at that lower end of the T3 range? We have someone, let’s say, lower end of the free T3 range, we’ll call it a 2.3, 2.4, or 2.5. If their baseline right there is good, symptom-free, feeling good, steady energy, not too high, not too low, they don’t need a nap at 2:00 PM, metabolism is nice and steady, all the things are pretty status quo or what we would consider optimal in terms of how do you feel-

Ari: Then leave them alone.

Dr. Amie: -leave them alone. It goes back to those people who are sensitive. We can’t push someone into a range just because we’re trying to hit a number. We can’t. Let me use estrogen as an example because women might understand this better, especially my menopausal ladies. I have a dear, dear friend. She’s in the health space. She is so sensitive to everything, T3 included, so I can loop her into this conversation as well with thyroid. Actually, let me pull back. I’ll use her thyroid labs because I remember them now. Her free T3 is indeed a 2.5. Her reverse T3 is like a 22. You would look at this profile and go– if you didn’t know her, you would look at the profile and go, “Oh my gosh, this poor woman, she’s got to be tired all the time and easily overweight and losing her hair.

No, I’m sorry. My friend is beautiful and thin and healthy and has no outward signs of thyroid dysfunction at all. She was like, “Well, maybe I need a little bit of energy.” I’m like, “Okay. I’ll give you 2.5 micrograms of T3 compounded. It’s a very, very, very, very low dose. Let me give you that and let’s see if we can’t change.” Nope. She reacted like that. Immediately, this tiny little dose just jacked her through the roof. She felt overstimulated. Now, did it move her number? No, it didn’t even have time to move her number. She’d be acid to that.

Ari: This is exactly the example that I was referring to.

Dr. Amie: This same poor woman, if I give her a drop too much of estrogen, she blows up like a balloon and gets all weepy and hates life. It’s the same thing. It’s like when you have those sensitive people, you don’t have to do much, sometimes nothing at all, because they’re fine right where they are.

Why Low T3 Doesn't Always Need Treatment

Ari: I want to talk a bit about iodine and the autoimmunity story because this is an area where still I see a lot of widespread, let’s say, confusion and controversy in a pretty wild way, if you think about it. On the one hand, we have this logic that says, “Well, iodine is really important for thyroid function. Therefore, if you have low thyroid, make sure you take your iodine to get your thyroid functioning well.” We see lots of thyroid support supplements with iodine in them for that reason, or practitioners even advising to take iodine as its own supplement or to take seaweed and things like that.

Then on the other hand, you have practitioners who are actively warning against iodine toxicity as a cause of autoimmune hypothyroidism. Again, it’s this really wacky, wild landscape with totally contradictory advice where people are potentially giving you the advice that might be causal of autoimmune hypothyroidism. Where do you land on this? What’s your take on that landscape?

Dr. Amie: I bring in common sense. I’m the person that comes in and goes, “Why can’t we all just get along? It seems like you all are too extreme on either side.” Here’s the thing. I also look at science. You are correct. When we look at thyroid hormone, T3, T4, what is it? It’s L-tyrosine with three iodines attached to it, four iodines attached to it. Essentially, iodine is used to create thyroid hormone. We know that. What else do we know about iodine? We have receptors on our cells for iodine that compete with some toxic halides that you really don’t want attaching to those cells. You have fluoride, bromine or bromide, chlorine, all of which we are exposed to. Even as hard as you try to not be, we still have some exposure.

When we’re exposed to those toxic halides, which are very toxic to the thyroid, but they’re not so great for the rest of our body, if we don’t have enough iodine in our system, those toxic halides win at the receptor site for attaching. There’s that. We also know that iodine is great for viruses. It increases the P53. I think it’s a gene. It’s not a protein. It’s tumor suppressive, so it helps with suppressing cancer mutation. All around, it’s like, “Wow, iodine seems pretty cool.” The problem is that years ago and still to this day, practitioners will overuse and over-recommend.

When we overdose iodine, we can easily send you into a thyroid storm, which you will go very hyper very quickly. Then we can also potentially increase antibodies through the use of iodine. It all comes down to the dose. It really comes down to the dose and the type of iodine. What do I mean by that? Number one, whenever we start off using iodine, if I’m starting a patient on iodine, I’m going to start her so slow, it will blow your mind. Literally, one tiny drop. I like using liquid because you can control it. If you take a 12.5 milligram tablet, try to break that up into one milligram, that’s really, really hard to do.

I like using liquid. We start very slowly. I educate that person to go, “Okay, when you go up from one drop to two drops, I want you to hold there and I want you to pay attention to your body,” because ultimately, we all have to train people to be in tune with their body. How do you feel? Do you feel like you drank five cups of coffee? Did you all of a sudden go, “Whoa, okay, wait a minute.” I call it icky and sticky. All of a sudden, I’m sweating and I’m jittery and I’m a little bit anxious and I’m hyped up and I feel right. Okay, well, you went too high.

Take some salt, take some vitamin C, skip your iodine the next day and the next time you go back to it, go back to the dose that you were on before where you felt good. You titrate up very, very, very slowly. You pay attention to your body and your body’s response, and if at any time you feel like you are tipping into that hyper state, you back down. I do believe that some iodine is vital, it’s key, it’s amazing and has so many benefits to it when used the right way. It’s like T3. If you’re going to dump T3 on somebody, you’re going to send them hyper, you’re going to have issues. If you do it the right way and you have them titrate up to their unique dose that works for their body, and they feel their best, then that’s what we’re supposed to be doing. Same thing with iodine. I don’t say to avoid it. I say to start low and slow and pay attention.

Ari: Dr. Amie, is there anything– First of all, I want to say this has been a really interesting discussion so far, and I really appreciate your answers. I think we’ve covered a lot of cool angles that are not necessarily normally covered in thyroid-related podcasts. Just before we wrap up, is there anything that jumps into your mind as an important topic that we should cover before we finish this conversation?

Thyroid Hormone Replacement vs. Natural Approaches

Dr. Amie: I would just leave everyone with this. It’s not that we didn’t cover, we did cover it beautifully, but on that thyroid hormone replacement piece, I run into this a lot. A lot of people, because they want to do things naturally, and we train them in the lifestyle and the supplementation and the nutrition components, there’s so many things that we can do that don’t require a pharmaceutical, that we almost put a little gold star on ourselves like, “I don’t take any medication. Yay, me. I’m all natural.” When it comes to optimizing your thyroid or even your sex hormones, none of us are getting– if you live long enough, you’re going to lose your hormones. We’re not escaping that. We haven’t figured out how to age in reverse yet. Whether it’s hormones or thyroid hormone replacement, so bioidentical hormone replacement, thyroid hormone replacement, sometimes you just have to be open to that hormone replacement. You almost have to put it in a different category. I do put the Band-Aid medications, like the statins and the birth control pills and the antidepressants and the PPI, those are the medications. Your doctor will write you a script for that in a heartbeat. You go in, you ask for an antidepressant, he’ll be like, “Which one? Let me write you five.” Those are the meds that we want to avoid.

I want everyone to just keep an open mind. If we can replace a hormone that’s no longer being properly made by your body that allows you better functioning, better circulation, better brain function, better mood, better metabolism, gets rid of your constipation, helps with joint pain, and protects you against the diseases of aging, because when we are talking thyroid, we tend to talk about how we look, feel, and perform. We don’t talk enough about the increased risk of cancer, the increased risk of Parkinson’s.

That’s a recent study that just came out where low thyroid function will affect Parkinson’s. We need to open our minds to go, “Okay, if I need hormone replacement, if it gives me better quality of life and extends my longevity, then I’m open to that. I just want to open people’s minds up so they’re not locked down thinking, “Oh, I don’t want that medication. That’s in that medication category that I avoid.”

Ari: Yes. Thank you for that. Dr. Amie, where do you want to direct people? Where do you want to let people know about your work? Where can they find out more about you and your program, services, anything you have to offer?

Dr. Amie: Absolutely. Thank you. You can go to dramie.com, D-R-A-M-I-E.com. From there, you can navigate all around. You can click on the store button, shop. You can go over there and check out some tea, too. Up in the other corner, you can book a call. This is a call to work with us in the clinic where we prescribe to all 50 states. We specialize in thyroid hormones. Yes, we do peptides, all the things. That’s where it’s your time to find out more about us, and then we are going to find out more about you and figure out if you are the right fit. If you’re not, we’re going to refer you out.

Either way, we can help you unpack your health. We have so many collaborative partners that we refer out to. We’ll take care of you. We’ll be honest with you. If you’re not a good fit for us, we’re going to send you where you should be. If you are a right fit, then we’re going to talk to you about how we can absolutely help you in that thyroid hormone department because we do it blindfolded with our eyes closed in our sleep. That’s our jam. That’s what we do so we can absolutely fix you. That’s the best place to go. The Thyroid Fixer podcast, Ari has been a guest on that as well. We’ve got to have you back on, too. It’s been too many years.

Ari: Yes, I would love that.

Dr. Amie: Seriously. That’s a great resource for all things, everything that we’re talking about today.

Ari: Awesome. Dr. Amie, thank you so much for coming on again. It was a great pleasure reconnecting with you.

Dr. Amie: Absolutely. Thank you.

Show Notes

00:00 — Introduction: Thyroid Health With Dr. Amie Hornaman
00:51 – Why Conventional Thyroid Care May Miss Symptoms
04:00 – Thyroid Hormones, Depression, Anxiety and Mental Health
05:59 – Hashimoto’s, Autoimmunity, Black Cumin and LDN
08:56 – Black Cumin Seeds vs. Oil: Understanding Thymoquinone
10:50 – What Is T2? The Forgotten Thyroid Hormone
13:33 – T2, Metabolism, Fat Burning and Muscle Mass
17:22 – T2 Supplements: Availability and Practical Uses
19:30 – T2 Side Effects, Thyroid Suppression and Dosing
24:57 – Low Free T3: When Should Thyroid Hormones Be Treated?
31:29 – Low T3 in Athletes: Healthy Adaptation or Hypothyroidism?
34:02 – The Risks of Too Much Thyroid Hormone
36:10 – Normal Thyroid Labs but Still Feel Awful?
39:52 – Why Low T3 Doesn’t Always Need Treatment
43:25 – Why Low T3 Doesn’t Always Need Treatment
49:17 – Thyroid Hormone Replacement vs. Natural Approaches

Recommended Podcasts

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Leave a comment

Scroll to Top